Florida Drops Its Bump-Stock Ban Defense: What Changes, and What Does Not
80 Percent Arms | Nov 16th 2026
A signed opinion says the office will not defend convictions under section 790.222. The statute itself is still law, and the federal parts-kit fight runs on its own clock.
On November 13, 2026 Florida Attorney General James Uthmeier issued a signed opinion declaring that Florida's bump-fire stock ban violates the Second Amendment. His office said it will not defend convictions brought under the statute. That is a real shift for a state that has banned these parts since 2018. It is not repeal, and it does not touch federal law.
The ban stands. The defense quit.
What happened: Attorney General James Uthmeier issued an opinion on November 13, 2026. It says section 790.222, the bump-fire stock ban, violates the Second Amendment. His office will stop defending convictions under it.
What did not change: The statute is still law. Only the legislature can repeal it. Judges owe the opinion no deference, and county prosecutors can still file cases.
Federal side: 80 percent lower builders live under a separate federal dispute. The parts-kit rule survived at the Supreme Court in 2025, on statutory grounds. A Texas court struck it as applied in August 2026, and both appeals are live at the Fifth Circuit.
Eight dates that explain the whole fight
Full bar is the settled part of that step. The 2027 line is a planned window, not an event.
| Date | Event | Status |
|---|---|---|
| Mar 9, 2018 | Gov. Rick Scott signed the Marjory Stoneman Douglas High School Public Safety Act; the ban is s. 13 of ch. 2018-3 | Law |
| Jun 16, 2025 | Repeal bill HB 6013 died in the House Criminal Justice Subcommittee | Dead |
| Mar 26, 2025 | Bondi v. VanDerStok upheld the federal parts-kit rule on statutory grounds | Federal |
| Aug 17, 2026 | On remand, a Texas district court found the federal rule unconstitutional as to the plaintiffs | On appeal |
| Oct 9, 2026 | The government appealed to the Fifth Circuit; plaintiffs cross-appealed Oct 16 | Appeal |
| Nov 3, 2026 | Uthmeier elected to a full term, defeating Jose Javier Rodriguez | Elected |
| Nov 13, 2026 | Signed opinion: s. 790.222 violates the Second Amendment; office will not defend convictions | Opinion |
| 2027 | Next regular legislative session: the only certain fix is repeal | Planned |
What moved, and what stayed put
Read the opinion closely and it splits into two columns: what changed on November 13, and what did not. The second column is the longer one.
Only two of the three tracks are filled, and that is the whole story: the opinion pulls one actor off the field.
| Question | Answer | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Is s. 790.222 repealed? | No | Only the legislature repeals; HB 6013 and HB 6021 both died in committee |
| Is it still a felony to possess a banned item? | Yes | Third-degree felony, up to five years, per the statute text |
| Do Florida courts have to follow the opinion? | No | Attorney General opinions are advisory |
| Will his office defend a conviction? | No | The opinion says so, in terms |
| Is the federal parts-kit rule settled? | No | Upheld on statutory grounds in 2025; constitutional ruling on appeal to the Fifth Circuit |
| Are true auto-sear conversion devices covered? | No | The opinion carves out devices that truly convert a semiautomatic into a machinegun |
What the opinion actually says
The ban lives in section 790.222. It arrived inside the Marjory Stoneman Douglas High School Public Safety Act, signed by Governor Rick Scott on March 9, 2018. The statute defines the banned item broadly, down to "a conversion kit, a tool, an accessory, or a device" used to mimic automatic weapon fire. It also reaches anything that speeds a semiautomatic past unassisted human fire. Bump stocks are never named. The ban works by description, and the Attorney General reads it to cover trigger enhancers.
Working under the Supreme Court's Bruen text-and-history framework, Uthmeier made three findings. First, the stock itself is protected. The opinion: "A rifle's stock is an integral component of the weapon itself." It lists bump stocks beside trigger lightening kits, buffer weights, springs, and short and forced reset triggers. The opinion cites ATF's estimate of over half a million bump-fire stock devices in private hands. That number makes an unusual-device story a hard sell.
Second, the state cannot justify the ban with history. In the opinion's words: "I am unable to find such a tradition. Repeating and quick-firing arms are not a modern innovation." Lever-action and revolving rifles outran the muzzle-loaders before them. Until 1986, federal law let civilians buy registered machineguns.
Third, the opinion says what it does not protect. It reserves the government's power over devices that truly convert a semiautomatic into a machinegun. A true auto-sear conversion sits outside this opinion. Anything that only changes reset speed sits inside it.
Federal and state: two different clocks
The parts-kit rule is the federal fight that reaches 80 percent lower builders. The Supreme Court upheld it in Bondi v. VanDerStok, decided March 26, 2025. That ruling was statutory, not constitutional. The Court reversed the Fifth Circuit and remanded with the constitutional questions open. The ruling's words: "The ATF's rule is not facially inconsistent with the GCA."
That court, case number 4:22-cv-00691, answered them on August 17, 2026. It found the rule unconstitutional under the Second Amendment and void for vagueness, resting on the Due Process Clause. The relief is narrow. It runs to the named plaintiffs and the products the judgment names, and it vacated nothing. That same court granted the government summary judgment on the plaintiffs' administrative-law counts.
Both sides then appealed. The government filed on October 9, 2026. The plaintiffs filed on October 16, seeking relief broader than their own products. Federal law on unfinished receivers is genuinely unsettled, and no state official can settle it.
In Florida the picture differs in kind. The state's top lawyer says the component ban is void as written, and his office will not defend prosecutions. The statute still survives, and courts are still not bound. Only repeal changes that.
The counter-case, stated straight
Plenty of people will fight this opinion. Prosecutors who built cases under the ban can decline advice they were never required to accept. Attorneys general change, and later opinions reverse earlier ones. Courts have no duty to adopt the office's reading. His X post said people are being arrested and prosecuted under a 2018 law that banned "bump stocks," and the opinion adds the constitutional frame. The opinion is the most persuasive document in the state on this question. Persuasive is not binding, and it protects no one from a case that was already filed.
The ban also arrived with real public backing. It was part of a bipartisan response to a mass shooting. Supporters of rate limits argue, reasonably, that a device built only to fire faster is no ordinary accessory. That argument failed under Bruen. It has not failed in politics, which is why repeal is the only permanent fix.
What owners should do
- Read the opinion before you buy. It runs six pages and is the closest thing Florida has to a rulebook for rate-of-fire components right now. The signed opinion is public record.
- Check the line between component and converter. Trigger resets and bump stocks sit inside the opinion's reasoning; true auto-conversion devices are explicitly outside it.
- Keep your receipts and your dates. Enforcement posture shifts with administrations, and your purchase record is what anchors your position.
- Push for repeal, not just non-enforcement. HB 6013 died in committee on June 16, 2025. Its successor HB 6021 died in the same subcommittee on March 13, 2026. Contact your Florida representatives before the 2027 session and ask them to carry a repeal out of committee, at flsenate.gov and flhouse.gov.
- Federal builders: watch the December 2 argument. The Supreme Court hears Viramontes v. Cook County and Grant v. Higgins on December 2, 2026. The question is whether the right to keep and bear arms covers the AR-15 platform and similar rifles. That ruling, not Florida's, sets the national line.
Read next
One category, one stop: AR-15 80 lowers and receivers.
We are not lawyers, and this article is not legal advice or a legal opinion. Reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. Gun laws change often and differ by state and locality, and we do not track every jurisdiction. It is your responsibility to know and follow all applicable local, state, and federal laws, including but not limited to the Gun Control Act of 1968 and any state or local rules that apply to you. Eligibility rules, including age limits and who is prohibited from possessing a firearm, vary as well. Before you buy, build, or ship anything, confirm the current rules where you live with the ATF, your state and local authorities, and a qualified attorney. If you are unsure, talk to an attorney first.
AR-platform 80 lowers and kits, shipped to eligible states.
Browse AR-15 80 lowers