Maryland Carry Map Stands: 80 Lower Owner Takeaways
80 Percent Arms | Nov 17th 2026
The Court refused to review a Maryland carry case on Monday, and the appellate ruling behind it now governs in full.
The Supreme Court on Monday refused to hear Novotny v. Moore, a Second Amendment challenge to Maryland's list of places where carrying a handgun is a crime. The denial leaves the Fourth Circuit's January 2026 ruling in place, so Maryland's carry map now governs in full. For an owner of a personally manufactured firearm (PMF), the decision is not about how you build. It is about where you can carry.
Maryland's carry map stays in force.
- What happened: On November 16, 2026, the Supreme Court denied review in Novotny v. Moore (No. 25-1324), leaving a Fourth Circuit decision from January 20, 2026 that upheld most of Maryland's sensitive-places restrictions.
- What changed: Nothing on the merits. A denial grants no precedent and endorses no reasoning. The law, SB 1, and the appellate ruling behind it stand.
- What is pending: Justice Thomas agreed with the denial but called for a narrower case on where states may ban carry. The Second Amendment Foundation says it has that case already, Christian v. James, on New York's park carry ban.
- Next step: If you carry in Maryland or travel the Fourth Circuit, map your routes against the restrictions that now bind and recheck your own state's list.
What the Court actually did
The refusal came in the order list from the justices' private conference of November 13, released Monday morning. The petition asked one question: whether Maryland's "numerous prohibitions on carrying firearms in many places frequented by the general public" violate the Second and Fourteenth Amendments. Four justices were needed to hear the case; they did not.
A cert denial is a no to the case, not a yes to the law. It sets no national rule. What it does is freeze the ruling below, and that ruling, from a consolidated Fourth Circuit appeal decided January 20, 2026, covers a long list of public venues.
What survived
Maryland Governor Wes Moore signed SB 1 on May 16, 2023, and challengers were in court the same day. The restrictions reached government buildings, school grounds, public transportation, state parks, stadiums, and places that sell alcohol. The appeals court held all but one of the challenged sensitive-place restrictions consistent with the Second Amendment, as Newsweek reported it.
So the practical picture in Maryland is a carry permission surrounded by zones. School grounds and government buildings were never in doubt. The contested venues, parks, transit, entertainment sites, and drinking establishments, are the ones that now stand.
The statement that matters more than the denial
Justice Thomas agreed with the refusal but called it a procedural judgment, not an endorsement. In a statement released with the order, he said he was skeptical that each Maryland restriction tracks the Nation's historical tradition of gun regulation. The breadth of the challenge, many locations at once, is what made the case a poor vehicle, he said. Then he pointed the way: in a narrower case, he wrote, the Court should weigh a state's authority to ban firearms in sensitive places.
Thomas also widened the frame past Maryland. States now prohibit firearms in categories of places that bear little resemblance to the courthouses and legislative halls the Court has historically recognized. His statement, as reported by Newsweek, put California at 29 gun-free categories, New Jersey at least 25, and New York some 20. Those lists, he wrote, stand on questionable historical ground.
The next vehicle
Two follow-ons are already in motion. The Second Amendment Foundation's Bill Sack told Newsweek the group is disappointed by the denial but has a case pending that fits Thomas's spec: Christian v. James, challenging New York's sensitive-places carry ban in public parks. Separately, the Court is set to hear Viramontes v. Cook County and Grant v. Higgins this term, consolidated cases on whether state bans on AR-15-style rifles violate the Second Amendment. That fight is about what you may build and own, not where you may carry, but it lands on the same households.
What this means if you built your handgun
Location laws attach to the carry, not to the factory. If you lawfully possess a handgun you finished from an 80 lower, Maryland's zones apply to your carry the same way they apply to a factory gun. Building at home does not buy a pass through a school zone or a state park, and this denial does not make one.
Two habits keep you covered in this environment. First, carry laws and PMF laws are two separate checklists. Some states allow the build but restrict the carry; others register the build yet allow carry. A few restrict both. Verify each list in every state you travel through, from primary sources, not from a vendor page. Second, treat any court status as a snapshot. This order is the record as of November 17, 2026. Denials, stays, and injunctions shift without notice.
One fact cuts the other way. Maryland told the Court that lower courts already agree, in the main, on where guns may be restricted. The state called it "vast areas of shared consensus". Consensus built on contested historical analogies is stability, not resolution. The 2026 term already saw the Court strike down Hawaii's rule on private property open to the public, in Wolford v. Lopez, which suggests the doctrine is still moving.
Where this lands for us
We machine receivers and jigs because we think the right to build your own firearm is real. A right that exists only wherever a legislature has not yet drawn a line around it is not much of a right. We support the narrowing of the sensitive-places doctrine that Thomas laid out, and we will keep reporting each order in these cases as it enters the docket.
Your next steps
- Re-read your state's carry statute this month, start to finish, and mark every location type that now applies to you.
- Track Christian v. James and the AR-15 cases through SCOTUSblog's case pages; grant orders arrive without much warning.
- Keep your build records current, and re-verify the rules in any state where you plan to carry or ship before you act.
- If you carry, train against the map, not just against the drill: know exactly where your permission stops.
Florida Drops Its Bump-Stock Ban Defense: What Changes, and What Does Not
Minnesota AR-15 Ban Status: What 2027 Means for an 80 Lower
If you want to see what a compliant build looks like from our side of the bench, start with 80 lower receivers and build kits.
We are not lawyers, and this article is not legal advice or a legal opinion. Reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. Gun laws change often and differ by state and locality, and we do not track every jurisdiction. It is your responsibility to know and follow all applicable local, state, and federal laws, including but not limited to the Gun Control Act of 1968 and any state or local rules that apply to you. Eligibility rules, including age limits and who is prohibited from possessing a firearm, vary as well. Before you buy, build, or ship anything, confirm the current rules where you live with the ATF, your state and local authorities, and a qualified attorney. If you are unsure, talk to an attorney first. This reflects the court record as of November 17, 2026; a denial, stay, or injunction is not the final word, so confirm current status before acting.
- Supreme Court docket, No. 25-1324 (Novotny v. Moore)
- SCOTUSblog case page: Novotny v. Moore
- SCOTUSblog order-list report by Amy Howe and Kelsey Dallas (Nov. 16, 2026)
- Newsweek coverage of the denial and Justice Thomas's statement (Nov. 16, 2026)
- Maryland Matters: Supreme Court won't take up Maryland gun rights case (Nov. 17, 2026).